Original article
Reform on Paper, Abuse in Practice: Have Saudi Arabia’s Labour Reforms Reached Female Kenyan Migrant Workers?
“I am so afraid,” Ms. Muthoni, 40, said in a phone interview last month. “I don’t think I can endure those lashes.”
A Saudi court has sentenced Ms. Muthoni, a Kenyan migrant worker, to 100 lashes for giving birth outside marriage. The ruling, issued last month, reflects the persistent failure of a decade of social and legal reforms to meaningfully improve protections for migrant workers in a kingdom where women can be jailed and punished for “illegal pregnancy.”
The experiences of Kenyan migrant domestic workers demonstrate that the abuse and exploitation of women in Saudi Arabia are not isolated incidents, but the result of systemic failures that have persisted for decades. Despite years of international scrutiny and repeated recommendations, Saudi Arabia has failed to adequately protect these women or hold those responsible for their abuse accountable. The November 2026 visit by the UN Special Rapporteur on Violence Against Women presents an important opportunity to bring these experiences to the forefront of international attention and assess whether Saudi Arabia’s promised reforms have translated into meaningful change.
Saudi Arabia’s Treatment of Women Faces UN Review
The Special Rapporteur (“SR”) on Violence Against Women and Girls is visiting Saudi Arabia from November 8–18, 2026 to conduct an objective review of Saudi Arabia’s measures to “prevent, combat, and eliminate violence against women and girls, and to provide redress for victims and their families.” Following her visit, she will present a report of her findings and recommendations to the UN Human Rights Council.
The SR released a “Call for Input”, inviting any interested individual or organisation to submit information they have regarding Saudi Arabia’s adherence to international laws and standards on “women’s rights and the elimination of violence against women and girls based on intersecting grounds.” The SR particularly asked for information relating to topics such as trafficking, discrimination in the workplace, sex- and gender-sensitive migration policies, and access to justice for women and girls who are victims of discrimination and violence. Migrant women were specifically listed as a priority group for review of their treatment in Saudi Arabia.
This will not be the first time the SR on Violence Against Women and Girls visits Saudi Arabia. In 2008, the SR visited and reported her findings to the UN Human Rights Council the following year. Within that report, the SR identified migrant workers as a specific group that continues to experience unchecked gender-based violence in Saudi Arabia. (pg. 12). The report recognises the slave-like conditions to which female migrant workers are subject, including the confiscation of their passports and forced labour in isolated conditions that make them more vulnerable to abuse. (pgs. 16–17). The report also highlights multiple factors that contribute to these continued dangers, including the Kafala system (a legal system which ties the worker to an employer who acts as their sponsor and retains control over their movement), restrictive and segregative cultural practices towards women, isolation, community and government prejudices against migrants, and the lack of a tracking system for these workers. (pg. 18).
The 2009 report also noted Saudi Arabia’s lack of legal protections for migrant workers such as overtime pay or limits on hours. (pg. 22). Furthermore, Saudi Arabia does not offer adequate access to justice and social protection for migrant workers. (Id.) From these findings, the SR made multiple recommendations urging Saudi Arabia to abide by its international legal obligations and improve protections for female migrant workers, such as:
- Adopt legal protections for migrant workers
- Reform the Kafala system
- Investigate and prosecute employers abusing their workers
- Provide shelters and legal aid to migrant workers who are victims of abuse
- Raise awareness in the general population about domestic worker rights. (pg. 26).
Despite these recommendations, made in 2009, the same issues persist 17 years later. The concluding observations from Saudi Arabia’s most recent 2024 UN review under the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women stressed the CEDAW Committee’s continued concern for female migrant domestic workers. However, in its “Vision for 2030,” Saudi Arabia recently announced that it has abolished the Kafala system, which plays a large role in facilitating these human rights abuses. The SR’s current visit is a good opportunity for international bodies to investigate whether these changes are actually being implemented and what kind of effect, if any, the purported reforms are having on the conditions for female migrant workers.
The persistence of these abuses raises serious questions about whether Saudi Arabia has meaningfully implemented the recommendations it received nearly two decades ago. To help answer that question, Global Justice Kenya (“GJK”), in partnership with the University of San Francisco School of Law’s International Human Rights Clinic (“the Clinic”), documented the experiences of Kenyan women who travelled to Saudi Arabia for domestic work between 2008 and 2025. In September 2026, we made a submission responding to the SR’s Call for Input, detailing our findings from reviewing 247 cases of Kenyan domestic workers who returned from Saudi Arabia, at least 102 of which involved sex- and gender-based violence. We conducted in-depth, trauma-informed interviews with 53 of these survivors, and their stories are supported by detailed sworn declarations. These findings reveal a pattern of violations that have persisted for decades and provide important evidence for the SR’s review.
Saudi Arabia’s International Obligations and Continued Violations
I. Forced Labour and the Exploitation of Migrant Women
Saudi Arabia has multiple international legal obligations to uphold regarding protection and equality for women. For example, Saudi Arabia has signed and ratified the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (“CEDAW”). As a state party to CEDAW, Saudi Arabia is required to follow the standards within the Convention. However, Saudi Arabia made a very broad reservation to the treaty in which it declared that if any terms of the Convention contradict Islamic law, Saudi Arabia is not obligated to follow the Convention. Saudi Arabia also has neither signed nor ratified the Optional Protocol, which would allow individual women or groups to submit complaints against Saudi Arabia directly to the CEDAW Committee. Nevertheless, Saudi Arabia is still bound to uphold the articles of CEDAW that do not contradict Islamic law. For instance, Article 11 requires signatories to “take all appropriate measures to eliminate discrimination against women in the field of employment.” This includes the right to free choice of profession, employment benefits, protection of health and safety in working conditions, and paid leave and social security in cases of retirement and sickness.
The stories of female Kenyan migrant workers demonstrate that Saudi Arabia has violated Article 11 in numerous ways. Forced labour is defined by the International Labour Organisation (“ILO”) as “all work or service which is exacted from any person under the threat of a penalty and for which the person has not offered themself voluntarily.” (See ILO Indicators of Forced Labour.) All 53 Kenyan women whom GJK and the Clinic interviewed in depth after they returned home from domestic work in Saudi Arabia meet every 2025 ILO indicator of forced labour. These include deceptive recruiting tactics, restriction of movement, intimidation and threats, physical and sexual violence, retention of identity documents, withholding of wages, abusive working conditions, and more. (Id.) Saudi agents or employers confiscate migrant workers’ passports upon arrival in Saudi Arabia, or, in some cases, Saudi immigration officers hand them directly to the agent or employer. As a result, most of the workers have little or no ability to leave the home where they are employed. For example, one survivor described her experience with the agents in Saudi Arabia: “[My agent] told me that I was not to leave my employer’s household, even if I had to crawl on my hands and knees [to] continue working.”
In addition to the forced, excessive labour, working conditions for migrant Kenyan women are inhumane and unsafe. These conditions remain unchecked by Saudi Arabia’s government, and Saudi police frequently fail to investigate employers and instead return migrant workers to these conditions when they attempt to escape.
One survivor’s experience reflects what many women endure; we will call her Jane. A Saudi agent confiscated Jane’s passport upon arrival and gave it to her employer; the agent told her this was a normal practice. Jane’s employer then forced her to work almost 20 hours a day with barely any rest. She had no annual or sick leave. Jane’s employer forced her to clean the house with harsh chemicals that burned her skin and refused to provide her with gloves. Jane’s employer beat her, denied her food, and even threatened her with death. After Jane managed to escape, she told Saudi police about the abuse and overwork, but they returned her to her employer and failed to investigate the violations. The abuse escalated after police returned her, to the point that her employer attempted to kill her. Desperate to escape, Jane jumped off the roof of the home. She was never the same after the abuse she endured in Saudi Arabia. In Jane’s own words: “I returned to Kenya in a wheelchair, and to this day, I have not healed. I cannot provide for my family, and I dream about the people who abused me wanting to kill me and beat me.”
There is a pattern in these cases where women experience horrific working conditions and abuse, attempt to escape, and are returned to their employer by the Saudi police. Saudi Arabia is aware of this issue and continues to do nothing to protect these women.
II. Failure to Protect Migrant Workers from Gender-Based Violence
In addition to the employment-related violations described above, Saudi Arabia also fails to protect female migrant workers from sex- and gender-based violence. CEDAW Committee’s General Recommendation No. 35 states that gender-based violence against women constitutes discrimination against women under CEDAW. Gender-based violence is also recognised as interdependent with other human rights such as the right to health, liberty and security of the person, and it may even amount to torture or cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment in circumstances such as rape. (pg. 5). The recommendation further extends states’ obligations by making them responsible for private actors’ violence against women if they “fail to take all appropriate measures to prevent as well as to investigate, prosecute, punish, and provide reparation for acts or omissions by non-State actors which result in gender-based violence against women.” (pg. 8).
Saudi Arabia has violated General Recommendation No. 35 of CEDAW because it has failed to prosecute or even investigate Saudi police officers or private employers who sexually assaulted or raped Kenyan migrant women. Furthermore, the cultural atmosphere, to which Saudi police contribute, creates an environment in which these women feel unsafe even reporting their sexual abuse. For example, one survivor’s employer starved her and beat her daily, sometimes multiple times a day. Her employer then began to rape her every week. He threatened to kill her if she told his wife. In addition to fearing that her employer would kill her if she reported it, she had also been told in Kenya, before she travelled to Saudi Arabia, that she could be beheaded if the man of the house sexually abused her. She did, however, manage to escape and report to the police that she was being forced to work, denied medical treatment, and starved by her employer. In response, the police called her employer within minutes and returned her to the home. After she was returned to the house, her employer beat her so badly that she was covered in bruises. He also poured scalding water on her, causing permanent scars. She took a picture of the burns, and her employer threatened her with a gun and forced her to lie on video by saying that she had burned herself in an accident.
The recent sentence of 100 lashes imposed on Ms Muthoni further exposes the vulnerability of women under Saudi Arabia’s current legal and social framework. Her case demonstrates how women can face severe punishment for conduct deemed socially or religiously unacceptable, despite the kingdom’s promises of reform. For female migrant workers, the threat of punishment for “illegal pregnancy” may also discourage victims of sexual violence from reporting abuse or seeking help for fear of criminal punishment. This further limits their access to justice and reinforces their vulnerability to exploitation and discrimination.
The pattern of discrimination and exploitation targeting female Kenyan migrant workers is systemic and widespread. These women have not received help or remedies from the Saudi government and have been forced to suffer in silence. For many of them, the trauma did not end when they escaped their employers or returned to Kenya. They continue to live with the physical and emotional consequences of the abuse they endured.
Even Where Reform Falls Short, Hope Must Not Fall Silent
The significance of the GJK and Clinic submission to the SR extends beyond placing individual experiences on record. It is also an opportunity to ensure that the international scrutiny Saudi Arabia has faced over the years translates into measurable change for the women whose lives remain affected by its labour and migration systems. The SR’s visit makes this especially timely. Our submission gives the SR documented evidence against which to assess the country’s assurances, engage with the authorities on specific failures, and formulate recommendations grounded in the experiences of the women most affected. It also provides a basis for questioning whether the reforms Saudi Arabia has presented under Vision 2030 have actually dismantled the structures and power imbalances that enable exploitation.
Saudi Arabia has maintained that it has replaced the Kafala system with a contractual model. However, the extent to which this represents genuine change remains contested. The labour reforms introduced in 2021 did ease certain restrictions on migrant workers, including allowing some to change employment without their employer’s consent. Yet domestic workers, the very group whose vulnerability is central to this submission, remain excluded from key protections under Saudi labour law. Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International have also documented how employer control, restrictions on movement, exploitation and barriers to justice persist despite these reforms. The distinction matters: abolishing a system in policy announcements is not the same as dismantling its practices in the lives of workers.
This is precisely why advocacy must continue. By presenting evidence from 247 cases, including at least 102 involving sex- and gender-based violence, GJK and the Clinic are contributing to an international record that Saudi Arabia cannot meaningfully address through declarations of reform alone. This submission gives the SR empirical evidence of concrete issues to examine: whether domestic workers can leave abusive employers without retaliation, whether they can access protection without being returned to their abusers, whether perpetrators are investigated and prosecuted, and whether survivors can obtain justice and reparation. These are not abstract measures of progress. They are practical tests of whether the rights recognised under CEDAW, particularly Article 11, and Saudi Arabia’s obligations as articulated by the CEDAW Committee in General Recommendation No. 35, are being respected in practice.
There is hope in what this process makes possible. Hope does not rest on a passive expectation of state compliance; it is forged when survivors and advocates refuse invisibility, invoke treaty obligations, and compel international oversight mechanisms to hold sovereign authorities accountable. The SR’s findings and subsequent recommendations to the Human Rights Council can provide an authoritative basis for sustained engagement with Saudi Arabia, strengthen the work of civil society organisations, and give migrant-sending countries such as Kenya further grounds to demand accountability and better protection for their nationals abroad. The submission helps ensure that the experiences of Kenyan women are not lost in broader discussions of labour reform or economic development. It places their lived experiences alongside the commitments that Saudi Arabia has made and asks that those commitments be measured against the lives they are supposed to protect.
Advocacy, therefore, is not simply about exposing what has gone wrong; it is about making it increasingly difficult for what has gone wrong to remain unaddressed. Every documented case, every international submission, and every recommendation followed through creates another opportunity to challenge impunity and secure meaningful change. For the women whose experiences inform this submission, the value of international attention will ultimately lie not only in being heard, but in whether their experiences help ensure that no other woman has to endure the same human rights abuses.

